It always seems somewhat tacky to venture into an argument over why someone was killed in Iraq—that is, when they weren’t trying to kill Americans or coalition forces—the point being simply that they were killed and that’s enough of a tragedy.
But honestly, this story of the kidnapped then released Italian reporter being shot at, and her Italian “secret service” detail being killed by Americans en route to the airport out of town, is turning into what sounds like another Liberal Party of Canada spin-o-rama. For example, the reporter worked for a pro-communist newspaper (…at least it wasn’t state-owned like Canadian media giant CBC).
But the OpinionJournal’s lead editorial explains further and questions the affect on American and coalition lives when feckless governments cede to kidnappers’ demands and pay ransoms: aren’t they simply buying American and coalition deaths, and extending the terrorists’ abilities into the future so more of this can happen after they’re long gone? Of course they are.
Italy’s Ransom
Rome adopts a policy of deliberately aiding terrorism.
OpinionJournal.com
Wednesday, March 9, 2005 12:01 a.m. ESTAmericans join Italians in mourning the death of Italian secret service officer Nicola Calipari, whose funeral was held in Rome on Monday. Agent Calipari died a hero last Friday, reportedly using his body to shield freed journalist/hostage Giuliana Sgrena from gunfire as their car approached American troops near Baghdad Airport. So perhaps Ms. Sgrena will also shed a tear for the Americans and Iraqis who will die because of the ransom that was paid for her release.
So far, all the world’s moral anger has focused on the claim that U.S. soldiers were reckless, or even tried to “assassinate” her, as Ms. Sgrena’s newspaper, the communist Il Manifesto, put it. But her claims in some interviews that her car was moving slowly and cautiously are contradicted by, well, Ms. Sgrena.
Her own account of the fateful journey, published Sunday, has them traveling so fast they were “losing control” and laughing about what an irony it would be if they had an accident after all that had happened. In other words, they probably looked like a suicide car bomber to a scared American solider who had to make a split-second decision at night. (The military declines to give figures on car bombs specifically for operational security reasons. But “explosive devices” of various kinds are by far the leading killers in Iraq, accounting for close to half of all deaths from hostile fire, and nearly twice as many as gunshot wounds.)
Arguably far more reckless was Italy’s decision to pay ransom—reportedly of $6 million or more—to secure her release. Italy is also believed to have paid ransom for the release of two aid workers taken captive last year. The Italians know the U.S. opposes the policy, which may be why Ms. Sgrena’s transfer to the airport was not sufficiently coordinated with U.S. forces.
Not only does paying ransom encourage more kidnapping—of Italians especially—it also puts money in the hands of the enemy in a country where $40 buys an automatic rifle and $200 an attack on U.S. forces. The shooting of a speeding car at a military checkpoint in a war zone is an unintentional tragedy, but the paying of ransom amounts to a policy of deliberately aiding terrorists.
PTBC was founded by Mr. Johannesen in 2000.
Contact Mr. Johannesen about this article using this form. Please refer to article's title.
FOLLOW @JoelJohannesen ON X!
- Say something. - Friday October 25, 2024 at 6:03 pm
- Keep going, or veer right - Monday August 26, 2024 at 4:30 pm
- Hey Joel, what is “progressive?” - Friday August 2, 2024 at 11:32 am
